Wednesday, January 5, 2011

RE: [NNSD] Police promotion

Now there is talk of taking disciplinary action against SP Kharel. I wonder how that could be justified! This is double punishment; not only depriving a deserving person promotion due to him but punishing him for daring to raise question against unfair treatment being meted out. This will adversely impact the morale of upright police officers of integrity.

It reminds me of an analogy where a person calling the head of state a fool is punished. He wasn’t punished for calling the VIP a fool. Rather, he was punished for leaking state secret!

With best regards,


Ratna Sansar Shrestha, FCA
Senior Water Resource Analyst

From: [] On Behalf Of Pant, Premraj
Sent: Tuesday, January 4, 2011 10:44
Subject: {Disarmed} RE: [NNSD] Police promotion
I think all should respect only the correct decisions, if SP Kharel is deprived being eligible for promotion it is not fair with him.

The issue is how to determine which one is the correct decision and CS to fights for a correct decision. In a society where civil societies still are questioned and struggling to prove its neutrality, means scenario is a divide & biased presence of CS on the basis of political alliance or faith. There is a much more need in CS to prove where they stand. Then only its pressure will have one voice to work for a correct matter, not for an attitude of gaining popularity by raising the issue only. Perhaps it’s a straight forward, only some like.
Prem Pant

No comments: