tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post19276197856999892..comments2023-10-29T13:10:12.686+05:45Comments on RatnaSansar Shrestha, FCA रत्न संसार श्रेष्ठ: जातिय संघियता मुलुकको अस्तित्वको लागि खतराRatna Sansar Shresthahttp://www.blogger.com/profile/01452682212801147488noreply@blogger.comBlogger7125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-54017671560178339842011-05-04T01:12:15.032+05:452011-05-04T01:12:15.032+05:45Ratna Sansarji,
Thanks for the article. You have ...Ratna Sansarji,<br /><br />Thanks for the article. You have given valid argument against ethnic federalism. In some places you seem to be personal. Was it necessary? This article will help to think twice before deciding on ethnic federalism.RBNhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/13949534337501860412noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-85642718896356450142011-05-03T16:05:06.411+05:452011-05-03T16:05:06.411+05:45This article is very good. The writer has shown th...This article is very good. The writer has shown the real picture of Nepal. Change is necessary but in name of change, our social integrity should not be breach. To uplift the minorities, socially back warded community or group's only solution is not the ethnic states. Obviously, Only the few castes are enjoying in national resources but we should find out its solutions in democratic practices. I do believe that maximum 6 states ok for Nepal as it has not large area of territory. The writers view of 3 states by naming water shades seems very new and innovative. I found this article must be the best of his articles published before. I hope writer will keep writing such good articles in the days to come. <br />Phurpa Tamang, AdvocatePhurpahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12206764717424951611noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-47306119582272007242011-05-03T12:59:07.377+05:452011-05-03T12:59:07.377+05:45Being a watershed management professional, I under...Being a watershed management professional, I understand what do you mean and your right argument. I endorse your views and recommendations. I wish you elaborate this and post for wider audiences.<br /><br />Rabin BogatiRabinhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08793688601948046706noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-84943380219722280342011-05-02T21:09:51.268+05:452011-05-02T21:09:51.268+05:45Whether Ratna Sansarji produces most brilliant arg...Whether Ratna Sansarji produces most brilliant arguments against federalism, the concept of federalism has already been enshrined in the Interim Constitution and our country has already been re-christened Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal. So let us not backtrack but start looking forward how can we make our new Nepal viable physically, economically and politically.<br />Soviet Union disintegrated because it was a loose federation: remember Russia and Ukraine - although they were part of USSR - were full fledged members of the UN?<br />USSR disintegrated because of the high handedness of Russian ethnic group (imposition of Russian language, lack of opportunities for non-Russians even in republics dominated by other ethnic groups, etc..).<br />Yugoslavia disintegrated also because of the high handedness of Serbs...<br />Nepal is in the same position where all other ethnic groups are dominated by Brahmins, Chhetris etc..<br />So, better to part company amicably rather than end up in violent clashes later on.adarshahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/11950725607114935351noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-13857264653657565542011-05-02T20:50:22.279+05:452011-05-02T20:50:22.279+05:45Very analytical and convincing arguments. I hope m...Very analytical and convincing arguments. I hope more people read it and think over it.<br /><br />D KandelDikendrahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/10672839269501999422noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-15273148720996117172011-05-02T20:46:14.562+05:452011-05-02T20:46:14.562+05:45Very much thought provoking and convincing argumen...Very much thought provoking and convincing arguments. It is time also to explore possibilities of how we can backtrack those who are holding the idea in favor of federalism without analyzing its implications. How can we expect the political leaders, who cannot take decision even in minor subjects, making appropriate decisions on such pertinent issues?<br /><br />Dinesh PantDineshhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04399868307771488748noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4101224948087276413.post-5620895587110959602011-05-02T20:32:38.758+05:452011-05-02T20:32:38.758+05:45A perfect analysis based on ground reality to Nepa...A perfect analysis based on ground reality to Nepal.L B Thapahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14924827368324336321noreply@blogger.com